Enough Railing On Brooks Raley

The Cubs optioned rookie starter Brooks Raley (0-2, 9.00) back to Triple-A Iowa on Monday, but that’s no reason to give up on the young left-hander.

After a disappointing major league debut at San Diego last week–7 earned-runs, 8 hits in 4.0 innings–Raley made a quality start–3 earned-runs, 6.0 innings–in his second outing against Cincinnati on Sunday, despite suffering the loss.

Having allowed 10 earned-runs on 13 hits through two starts suggests the kid still needs some seasoning. But let’s not jump to conclusions, either.


It’s typical for rookie starters to struggle badly during their first taste of big league action.

Current Cub, Matt Garza, went (3-6, 5.76 ERA) through his first nine major league starts with Minnesota.

Former Cub, Sean Marshall went (6-9, 5.59 ERA) in his first 24 starts with Chicago–before discovering he was actually better suited for the bullpen.

Greg Maddux, for heaven’s sake, went (2-4, 5.52 ERA) in his first six appearances (five starts), and (6-14, 5.61 ERA) during his first full season with the Cubs in 1987.

This isn’t to suggest Raley will become half as good as any of the pitchers mentioned above. Instead, it’s simply a reminder that it’s still too early to judge the kid after a mere two major league outings.


Like seemingly everything else with the Cubs these days, we’ll have to stay patient while Raley develops.

It would be more comforting, of course, if he pitched as well as Randy Wells did in his rookie season as a starter (12-10, 3.05 ERA), but we all know how that turned out, too.

It’s already been reported Raley will be summoned from Iowa in time to make his third start as part of a day/night double-header at Cincinnati on Saturday.

All the better. Raley needs the experience and it’s wise of us to just let the kid do his thing, as painful as that might be.



Filed under Cubs Blog

4 responses to “Enough Railing On Brooks Raley

  1. I read will they may bring him back up Saturday for there Double Header with the reds. New Rule change this year allows them to have one extra player on the roster for double headers.

  2. Yep. I’m anticipating Raley will be made available by the Cubs to start one of the DH games in Cincinnati. The more experience for the kid, the better :)

  3. high heat

    We will take him in Houston if Theo gives up on him!

  4. I’d assume the Cubs give Raley a longer look through the rest of the season and into spring training.

    However, I’m sure Theo & company would be willing to part with Chris Volstad…I dunno, say, for some donuts?!?

Your thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s