Remembering 2008 Cubs Comeback vs. Colorado

Remember the Cubs thrilling comeback win against Colorado in late May of 2008? I know many of you do and probably just immediately thought of Mark DeRosa’s dramatic 2-R HR.

For those of you with a foggy recollection, let me jog your memory a bit. The Cubs trailed 9-1 after five innings, but rallied for a 10-9 victory behind home runs from Henry Blanco, Kosuke Fukudome, Jim Edmonds, and the blast off DeRosa’s bat.

This wasn’t just a tremendous comeback in Cubs history, it was a staple win that legitimized the first place Cubs as the best team in the National League (Ah, now you remember!).

I bring this particular game up because it reminds me so much of the Cubs dramatic come-from-behind win on Thursday against Milwaukee; a game in which Chicago trailed 9-3, then tied the score 9-9 in the sixth only to enter the bottom of the ninth down 11-9 before scoring three runs to cap off a 12-11 victory.

The dramatics were eerily similar to 2008, with one exception being the Cubs scored all 12-runs Thursday without the benefit of a home run.

But as my good friend @jdgershbein (he’s as true-blue a Cubs fan as they come) reminded me, there’s one big difference between these two comeback games–the 2008 victory actually meant something.


Thursday’s win, as memorable as it should be, will most likely be forgotten in a season that’s on course to be remembered as one of the worst in franchise history.

I bet a significant portion of Cubs fans are still unaware this comeback even happened. Probably more don’t even care to know. But that’s the cost of doing business for a team playing 30-games below .500.

Thursday’s game was played in front of a crowd of less than 20,000 (and much fewer stayed to see Soriano’s walkoff hit 4:09 minutes after the first pitch) whereas the comeback win against the Rockies was finished out in front of a packed house at Wrigley Field.

That win four-years ago is exactly the kind of ‘memorable experience’ every baseball organization hopes for–the type that keeps its fans wanting more—and precisely what Thursday’s game was not.


The comeback against Colorado capped off an (18-11) month of May for the Cubs, gave them a five-game winning streak (which stretched to nine-games) and enthralled even the most fringe Cubs fans to pay attention to the team on a daily basis.

Thursday’s win, however, won’t share the same effect for the masses. But it does tell those of us sticking with the team through the bitter end a thing or two about the character of these young Cubs and their manager.

Most notably, the Cubs never gave-in despite playing out the string against another underperforming team, in front of another underwhelming home crowd.

Dale Sveum, to his credit, never threw-in the towel as evidence by his five pitching changes and substitution of what appeared to be a lackadaisical Bryan LaHair in favor of Alfonso Soriano.

The young guns of Castro, Rizzo, Vitters, Jackson, Valbuena and Castillo battled start-to-finish. Their young enthusiasm helped spark the play of veterans David DeJesus and Soriano.

”Those young guys don’t give up,” said Soriano.

While the effort is appreciated and does give the club something to hang its hat on this season, we can only be certain the Cubs will waste more ‘memorable games’ even with the most promising possibilities of the Cubs fielding a competitive team by 2015.

But when the Cubs do blossom from pretender to contender, and I’m confident they will, we’re sure to see many more unbelievable come-from-behind wins like Thursday’s. That, after all, is what good teams do–win crazy games and win a lot of them.

Only then, however, most Cubs fans will immediately think back to a late May game in 2008 when the Cubs rallied from down 9-1 to beat the Rockies.

Meanwhile, Thursday’s game will have already become a faint, if not forgotten, memory, just another meaningless win in a season filled with seemingly 100 unmemorable losses.

And to that I say, what a shame.

*Fun side note. The losing pitcher for the Rockies in the 2008 comeback win? Now current Cubs reliever, Manny Corpas :)



Filed under Cubs Blog

3 responses to “Remembering 2008 Cubs Comeback vs. Colorado

  1. The comeback against Colorado in ’08 pales WILDLY to the 9-0 comeback against Houston in ’89. That happened at the end of August (shoot…maybe the 29th) in the middle of a pennant race. That game ended in the final at-bat and featured EVERYTHING. Rafael Ramirez was a one-man wrecking crew. 2 HR, 7RBI, a grand slam to put the Stros up 9-0…the Cubs comeback started in the bottom of the 6th…they tied it in the 8th, won it in the 10th. As a Cubs fan, the ’89 win means much much more.

  2. Now you’re sounding like my buddy, JD! He speaks with the same enthusiastic tone about the ’89 comeback as you do :D (that was a little before my time covering the Cubbies)

    Regardless of where each comeback ranks, the point is those two thrillers actually MEANT something to Cubs fans. They’re life-long memories remembering some of the best of times in Chicago baseball!

    That’s where Thursday’s game, unfortunately, falls short. It just doesn’t mean much, if anything, to Cubs fans.

  3. Excellent post, BB.

    Ironically, the Cubs’ cardiac finish against Milwaukee came 23 years TO THE DAY that Dwight Smith capped off one of the most memorable Cub wins in the last several decades. On August 30, 1989, in what came to be known as “The Comeback Game,” Smith, a late-inning replacement, smacked a game-winning, tenth-inning single that brought the Cubs all the way back from a 9-0 deficit to a stunning 10-9 triumph. From that point, the team never lost an ounce of momentum in taking the then-National League Eastern Division crown.

    The point: When these games happen during a season that actually means something, they are magnified, amplified and glorified. The 1989 Cubs were post-season bound, and that game was late enough in the year to seed belief that the team could actually go deep into the playoffs. (They did, but we all know what happened when they ran into the Will Clark-Kevin Mitchell-Matt Williams triumvirate.)

    If 2012 were a season in which we could feel the magic happening with a month left to go, that 12-11 victory against the hated beer makers would have been super special. In a rebuilding year, albeit one showing a lot of promise for the future, this was just another game coming off the schedule. .

Your thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s