Bryan LaHair, All Star Game Both Flawed

When I first learned Bryan LaHair was DFA the one thing that came to mind was his All Star selection. 

Two months of hot hitting put LaHair in the Midsummer Classic when it shouldn’t have. That’s not Bryan’s fault, but rather the result of a flawed voting system for the All-Star Game.

The voting by both players and fans has become so fuzzy it’s hard to tell anymore if the All Star Game is more about baseball All-Stars or baseball Pop-Stars. 

By the time LaHair left Kansas City to rejoin the Cubs he was already relegated to a platoon role, eventually became a bench warmer and now he’s headed to the Japanese League. That’s not the story of a slumping All Star, but the tune of a player who can’t quite cut it in the big leagues.

When one of the game’s supposed ‘best’ players is out of the league in the same year he was selected an All Star, you know something is wrong with the voting system. Although, that’s a big assumption on my part that the All-Star Game remains a gathering place of the league’s very best players.

That may have been the case 20-25 years ago, but it isn’t any longer. For years now the All Star voting has been something of a crap-shoot, a confusing blur of opinions about what exactly makes a player an All Star.

Is it strictly performances based, is it a popularity contest, or is it both? Honestly most fans don’t seem to know, or worse, even care…and quite frankly the same can be said about many of the league’s players. 

Players tend to cast their votes like fans do, punching the ballot for fellow teammate or friends. In fact, it was LaHair’s peers who chose him over arguably more deserving candidates. In the end, the players wanted to see LaHair and that’s who they selected.

That’s not such a big deal if the All-Star Game remained an exhibition contest as it was prior to Bud Selig’s approval to fix World Series home field advantage to the outcome of the game (and that alone might be the single most ridiculous thing going in baseball).

But it is an issue when a player’s feel-good story trumps his rapidly declining production. Both leagues, after all, are trying to win an important game. And just how important? Well, imagine how the World Series might have played out differently if Justin Verlander was pitching Game 1 at home instead of on the road at San Francisco.

Nonetheless, you would think the general lack of excitement around the All-Star Game would get baseball scrambling to chart a better course for its summer break; that team owners would be unwilling to dole out player bonuses based on popularity vs. performance and that the league could still find a better way to rake in the tons of revenue generated by the All-Star Game festivities.

The biggest issue is baseball doesn’t seem to know what the All-Star Game is, or what it should be–aside from just being a money-maker for the league.

If the All-Star Game is about showcasing who the fans want to see play, and who the players want to see play, then drop the connection to World Series home field advantage and concentrate on putting forth the best exhibition contest the game’s ever seen. Bryan LaHairs welcomed.

Otherwise, allow each team to submit a list of candidates the managers and coaching staffs can choose from to build a team that’s best suited to actually win a one-game showdown with potentially huge implications tied to the World Series. Sorry Bryan, feel-good stories are no longer welcomed.

It frustrates the heck out of me baseball continues to botch a fine opportunity to grow the game because of its flawed All-Star voting system and an unclear direction for the All-Star Game itself.

Baseball needs to determine whether the All-Star Game is an exhibition for the fans or a meaningful game with World Series implications. What it can’t be is both, but unfortunately that’s currently how it’s being played out.

Until the league decides what the All-Star Game truly is, there’s no clear purpose to the voting. And that will always leave the players and fans more confused than captivated.



Filed under Cubs Blog

6 responses to “Bryan LaHair, All Star Game Both Flawed

  1. Hey Brian, I think it’s an odd story that LaHair is out the same season he was an All-Star … but I don’t think that’s necessarily what’s wrong with the game. If I remember correctly, LaHair’s stats (in my opinion) were about on par with Joey Votto’s up until the voting was going to close, or maybe a couple weeks before that. So to me the selection of LaHair was not terrible, if you’re going by the best players in baseball that year up until that point, which is how I view it.

    As far as World Series effects and stuff, we’re probably in agreement.

  2. Right. The problem with AS selections is viewpoint.
    Are we voting for an exhibition game or WS home field advantage?

    Good point about LaHair’s early numbers.
    He was leading Votto a few weeks before the AS voting ended.
    However, that’s when LaHair really started his downfall, at least based on the numbers.

    This isn’t for arguments sake or to rebuttal your opinion.
    But I posted the comparison stats below of LaHair and Votto up until the end of the AS voting.

    We can see how LaHair rode the wave of his firecracker hot start in April all the way to Kansas City.

    Thanks for checking in. Look forward to hearing from you again.

    76-games… .354/.476/.639 14 HR, 47 RBI


    66-games… .288/.369/.534 13 HR, 28 RBI

    LaHair’s avg. by month leading up to AS Game: end of April (.390), end of May (.308), end of June (.288)

    Shame it didn’t work out for Bryan during the entire season. But I’ll be rooting for him to have greater success in Japan.

  3. merril stouder

    What’s right with the all star game? Not much! I quit watching and voting. What happened to the oldtimers game? I suspect a series of things. Didn’t generate enough money for mob. Maybe the players wanted more money. The all -star game is a money machine and mob don’t care about what the fans want. Home run derby? The players should do it for kicks. Modern players for the most part aren’t concerned about fans. Only a few do charities cause its on their hearts the others for tax shelters. Its not the game I grew up with. I’m not saying my era was perfect but you wont find the boys of summer barnstorming. JUST POINT THEM TO THE CSSH. I’ll continue setting out all – star week cause the real stars and hero’s aren’t there anymore.

  4. Yep. The bottom line is baseball needs to first figure out what the AS Game means to the fans, the players and the league.

    That would clear up the voting confusion and would help find a system to entice players to participate.

    Obviously, if it’s going to take money for players to participate then that’s also an option.

    But to determine appropriate and fair financial compensation for All Star players there needs to be a more clear voting system.

    If it wasn’t for baseball being such a great game, I wouldn’t believe the league’s business sense would survive in this day and age.

  5. merril stouder

    I agree! I love baseball!

  6. Hey Brian, interesting to actually see the stats. At the time I was just recalling anecdotally. Looking forward to stopping by more often.

Your thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s